9th January 1973

A hotel porter goes on trial for murder

John Tilley, a 21-year-old kitchen porter at the Bon Port Hotel, stood trial for murdering 34-year-old chambermaid Margaret Weaver. Accused of beating her when he lost his temper, he pleaded not guilty.

Unfortunately for Tilley, the police presented evidence claiming that he had confessed to the killing – and he was also, seemingly, the last person to have seen her alive on 2 October the previous year.

Tilley and Weaver had been at a staff party to mark the end of the tourist season – and the hotel closing down for the winter – and been observed by the proprietor, a Mr Whiteman, leaving the kitchen together at around 1.30am as the party drew to a close.

When Weaver failed to appear for work the following morning, Tilley suggested that she’d left the hotel with someone other than himself, and that her room appeared to be locked and the light on. When interviewed by police that evening he said that she’d been drinking heavily and that he, Tilley, had tried to get her to stop. Once they’d left the kitchen, he said, they’d gone their separate ways.

But, the following day, Weaver’s body was found in a shallow grave about 60m from the hotel. Her skull was fractured in several locations, bloodstains that matched Weaver’s blood type were found in Tilley’s room and there were drag marks leading from his quarters to the field where she was discovered.

Police questioning

Tilley was brought in for questioning and, according to details recounted in his appeal later that year, he broke down and admitted to killing her after she’d called his girlfriend a slag.

As reported by the Birmingham Post, “Det Con Bisson said Mr Tilley put his head in his hands and began to sob after which he made ‘certain remarks’ which witnesses had jotted down on the page of a desk calendar.”

They then took a more formal statement, in which Tilley said, “It may sound stupid. I didn’t really want to kill her. All I wanted her to do was for her to apologise for calling Pearl what she did. I wasn’t drunk at all. I had a few and was merry, but I was angry at what she’d threatened to do to Pearl and all the names she had called her. I had no intention to kill her.”

Questions over the questioning

There was some question over whether the evidence was admissible in court, but eventually the judge and the Jurats decided that it was. Several days into the hearing, Tilley was called to the dock, but he refused to stand and, instead, changed his plea to guilty of manslaughter on the grounds that Weaver had provoked him. The Jurats retired to consider the evidence and, 15 minutes later, found him guilty of murder by unanimous verdict. He was sentenced to life imprisonment.

That wasn’t the end of the story, though. A subsequent appeal rested on how Sir William Arnold, the Bailiff, had handled the police evidence. His error, said Tilley’s representative, Douglas Randell, was not only allowing the Jurats to be present when the admissibility of the evidence was discussed, but allowing them to decide for themselves whether they should hear it. Randell also said that the Bailiff had “failed to direct the Jurats adequately during his summing up in determining the issue of provocation and as to the onus of proof on the defence of provocation”.

The Procurer, representing the Crown, said that the Bailiff had been right not to ask the Jurats to withdraw because they hold “magisterial office” and decide on matters of fact, a decision about which “is essential to the application of the law of admissibility of evidence”.

The appeal was heard by the Bailiff of Jersey, Sir Robert Le Masurier, who agreed with Randell and reduced the conviction from murder to manslaughter, in the process cutting Tilley’s sentence from life to twelve years.


FREE Guernsey history newsletter

Don't miss our weekly update on Guernsey's fascinating history. We promise never to sell your data to anyone else, and there's a super-easy unsubscribe link on the bottom of each email so you can leave whenever you want. We'll also keep you up to date with our latest book releases and early-bird discounts.


Other events that occured in January

Alderney elects its first president 1st
Guille and Alles open their library 2nd
Guernsey bans smoking in public places 3rd
Guernsey Press registers its domain 4th
Guernsey Zoo is sold as a going concern 5th
Guernsey opens its wartime files
Guernsey Police moves to its new headquarters 6th
Guernsey Fisher makes its maiden voyage 7th
Work begins on the Val des Terres 8th
A hotel porter goes on trial for murder 9th
Guernsey Police Service appoints its first inspector 10th
Royal theft inquiry heads to Guernsey 11th
Channel Express Airways plane crashes in Guernsey 12th
Sibyl Hathaway, Dame of Sark, is born 13th
Channel Television disappears 14th
Benefactor Osmond de Beauvoir Priaulx dies 15th
MV Prosperity is wrecked at Perelle 16th
Guernsey’s Royal Court sits for the first time 17th
Doctor Who travels to Guernsey 18th
Channel 4 gameshow Treasure Hunt comes to Guernsey 19th
Hanois Lighthouse is cut off by the weather 20th
Guernsey-built prototype plane crashes 21st
Guernsey Steam Tramway stops running 22nd
Radiant Med sinks with loss of life 23rd
Guernsey wins gold at the Commonwealth Games 24th
Sark is awarded Dark-Sky status 25th
Guernsey passengers are battered by storms 26th
Sir Isaac Newton has his say on a mysterious Guernsey invention 27th
Guernsey’s last witch trial takes place 28th
Guernsey poet George Métivier is born 29th
The States of Guernsey proposes a new airport 30th
Guernsey lifeboat performs a chemical tanker rescue 31st